Both onions and garlic fit into keto, but they sit in very different places, and lumping them together is where people go wrong. Garlic is so low-carb per clove that you can more or less ignore it. Onions are the sneakier one: they feel like a plain vegetable, yet they carry more sugar than their savoury taste lets on, and they end up in almost everything you cook. The trick is not to ban either, but to know which one needs watching and which one does not.
There is a stubborn belief that muscle only grows on a mountain of rice and oats, and that going low-carb means quietly waving goodbye to your gains. It is half true and half myth, and the half that is myth causes a lot of unnecessary worry. You can build muscle while eating keto. It asks for a bit more attention to protein and to how you train, and it will not always feel like your carb-fuelled sessions did, but the muscle itself does not check where your fuel came from before it decides to grow.
Early on, every keto beginner hits the same confusing fork: should you count net carbs or total carbs? The forums argue about it, the food labels muddy it, and the answer affects what you can eat. It is not as complicated as the arguments make it seem, but getting it right matters, so here is the honest version.
Newsletter
Get keto tips in your inbox Practical, evidence-minded notes on keto and low-carb living, with a Brussels slant.
People often talk about keto and carnivore as if they were two names for the same thing, and you can see why: both are low in carbohydrate, both put fat and protein at the centre of the plate, and both tend to attract the same crowd. But they are genuinely different diets, and the difference matters if you are trying to decide which one to follow. Keto is a low-carbohydrate diet with room for plants.
Yes, bone broth fits keto comfortably. A mug of it is almost entirely water, gelatine and minerals, with barely any carbohydrate, so it will not touch your ketosis. What makes it worth bothering with is not the carb count though, it is the salt and the warmth, both of which happen to solve two of the most common early-keto complaints at once. I keep a batch in the fridge through the colder months and reach for it on the days my legs feel heavy.
Keto carries a reputation as a rich person’s diet, all ribeye steaks, smoked salmon and tubs of almond flour. That version is indeed pricey, but it is a choice rather than a requirement. Strip keto back to whole foods and it becomes one of the cheaper ways to eat well, because the most expensive things on the plate, the processed convenience foods and the speciality “keto” products, are exactly the ones you can do without.
A well-built keto plate is not short on nutrition. Eggs, fish, meat, dairy and green vegetables are among the most nutrient-dense foods there are, and people often eat better on keto than they did on a beige diet of bread and cereal. Even so, cutting carbohydrate changes which vitamins and minerals you need to think about, and a couple of them slip low often enough to be worth naming. Here is what to watch and, more usefully, how to cover each one from the food already on your plate.
Short version: a can of diet cola has essentially no carbohydrate and no sugar, so it will not knock you out of ketosis, and plenty of people drink it happily on keto. Whether it is a good idea for you personally is a slightly longer conversation, because the worries about diet soda are less about carbs and more about sweeteners, cravings and habit. Here is what actually holds up and what does not, so you can make your own call rather than follow either the “totally fine” or the “poison” camp.
There is a stage of keto almost nobody plans for, and it is the one where the results are won or lost: coming off it. Plenty of people lose weight successfully and then pile it back on within weeks of returning to normal eating, conclude that keto does not work, and miss that the problem was the exit, not the diet. Done thoughtlessly, coming off keto produces a demoralising bounce. Done well, you keep most of what you gained.
Condiments are where a careful keto day tends to spring a leak. The food on the plate is fine, and then a generous squeeze of something sweet turns a low-carb dinner into a middling one. The good news is that the split is easy to learn: some condiments are almost pure sugar in disguise, while others are essentially free and can stay in daily rotation. Here is which is which, with rough carb counts so you can judge for yourself.